Aug 27, 2000 12:45 Hrs (IST)
New Delhi: Filmstar-turned-MP Shabana Azmi has criticized the government for
delaying the passage of the women's reservation bill that seeks to reserve 33 per
cent legislative seats for women.
She has dismissed as "ridiculous and irrational" the National Democratic Alliance
(NDA) government's argument that the bill suffers due to a lack of consensus among
political parties, and called it a "delaying tactic."
"If 60 bills could be cleared without consensus the government could have brought
this bill forward as well and put it to vote," Shabana told India Abroad News
Service in an interview at the conclusion of the monsoon session of Parliament.
Zealously pursuing the bill since her nomination to the Rajya Sabha, Azmi doubted
the motive of the ruling coalition in insisting on a consensus on the issue
of "women's empowerment". "We are only asking for sharing of power which the women
rightly deserve," she said.
Azmi also blamed the male-dominated political parties, except those from the Left
parties, for obstructing the bill. "The men are insecure that they would lose their
seats if the bill is passed," she said.
The film star is also not hopeful of an early passage of the bill even though Prime
Minister Atal Behari Vajpayee indicated during that his government would bring the
bill forward even if there were no consensus.
With state Assembly elections due in several states next year, ratification by
states could get delayed even if the bill was passed in Parliament, she feared. Azmi
also disagreed with the demand of a few political parties, notably the Samajwadi
Party, for a review of the bill and changes in its provisions.
"The reservation bill has been exhaustively debated at various platforms, from the
election commission to social organizations, where leaders and activists made
various recommendations," she pointed out.
"First let us pass the bill as it is," she said in response to a section's demand
that the reservation incorporate sub-quotas for the socially underprivileged
classes. As every state government differed with the other in its list of other
backward classes (OBCs), the change could take almost ten years to implement, she
said.
Affirmative action was needed to improve women's representation in Parliament as
their percentage of total MPs had risen from four per cent in the first Lok Sabha to
only eight per cent in the present one, she said.
In Azmi's perception, decision-making could benefit immensely with their increased
participation as women thought "differently" from men.
"They always talked about the development... the water problems, education of
children and health," she said of her recent interaction with women elected to
panchayats, or village councils. "But men are more bothered about constructing halls
or a center and having their names on it," she said.
The controversial bill, first drafted four years ago and promised by almost all
major political parties in their election manifestos, has languished through two
governments each of the United Front and the BJP-led coalition.
But Azmi also agreed that a majority of women's organizations were disunited on the
issue. She, however, dismissed a dominant argument that the number of women
qualified for people's representation was small. "If this is the logic, I can say
the same about men... this is very demeaning," she said.
While agreeing that in some cases the women elected to panchayats might have
been "proxy" candidates for men, she said, "But in my state Maharashtra, empowerment
of women has been brought about only through the panchayat system."
Azmi condemned the recent legislation in Madhya Pradesh, Rajasthan and Himachal
Pradesh that disqualifies contestants who have over two children. "This is anti-
women as they have no control on child-bearing," she said.
Azmi also opposed the election commission's suggestion that political parties
allocate 30 percent seats to women candidates. "The parties may give weak seats to
women... they will never make it to Parliament," she said.
India Abroad News Service