
On January 2, when senior Vishwa Hindu Parishad (VHP) leader Acharya Giriraj Kishore
hit out at Prime Minister Atal Behari Vajpayee describing him as a 'pseudo-Hindu',
it signified a turning point in a raging debate that has the taken the nation in its
grips.
Being attributed the "pseudo" tag to derogate is not a new phenomenon. The term
entered the political lexicon about a decade ago and its many users now have
pencilled in the word in any copies of dictionaries that they could lay their hands
on.
It is not unusual to walk into Higginbothams, a book store in New Delhi and find a
leather-bound copy of the Chambers dictionary with the word inserted, in almost
illegible, red ink amidst the black typeset.
In a curious coming around of what goes around, the Deputy Prime Minister L K
Advani, who first used the term on those who did not share his opinions was himself
called pseudo-secular not too long ago after some of his expressions in the
Parliament. Vajpayee has been at the brunt of the verbal attack since he
attended 'Iftar' hosted by the Civil Aviation Minister Shahnawaz Hussein.
The Muslim custom 'Iftar' is the breaking of the daily fast during the month of
Ramadan. The current charge by the Acharya emanated, however, when the PM apparently
spoke about the 'hindutva' movement in an address from Goa where he was vacationing.
The rapid use of the term and its political implications, not to mention its
literary precedents has forced Osmania University to institute a Department of
Pseudology (DoP). Dr Shridhar Khatri has been appointed as the chief pseudologist.
Dr Khatri comes in with his 20 years experience as a private, small animals
physiotherapist.
A search is on by a steering committee led by Dr Khatri to acquire all literature
with the term 'pseudo' in the title. The search has already brought in books as
varied as "Pseudo-random coding techniques for high speed communications"
and "Pseudo-Macarius: The 50 spiritual homilies and the great letter (classics of
Western spirituality)".
Being a new field, the current free users of the expression were contacted to
comment. The Acharya from VHP was unavailable, but his spokesman Mondkar was eager
with explanation. "If you are a Hindu and attended 'Iftar', then you are a pseudo-
Hindu. But if you are secular and attended 'Iftar' then you are pseudo-secular," he
said. If you were Hindu and secular and attended 'Iftar', then you became a pseudo-
secular-Hindu. He went on to shorten the double hyphenation and called them "pseudo-
secuindoo".
By analogy, a secular Muslim that went to 'Iftar' would be 'pseudo-seculim'. Mondkar
was ready with responses to various questions on how the 'pseudo' label gets
attached. For example, he said, "If you were a pregnant-Kashmiri and
attended 'Iftar', then you were pseudo-pregnant."
Khatri, chief pseudologist at the DoP said Mondkar of the VHP was simplifying the
pseudo-concepts. He said in certain cases this was related to attending 'Iftar' but
the matter was not quite as trivial. He said there was a big identity crisis amongst
Indians today. Many of them did not know for sure if they were real or 'pseudo'. He
went as far as to say that India's population was only 50 crore. The other 50 crore
did not exist as they were all 'pseudos'.
The usage has not been very negative in all circles. Mullah Shabir of the Karimnagar
Masjid has requested the VHP to call him 'pseudo'-something. He said it sounded very
good. The Mullah, who is a former weaver said he was on the look out for a nice
English-sounding title. He didn't care what it meant.
In the Southern state of Tamil Nadu (TN), pseudo-secularism has taken a different
meaning altogether. Advani's old slur was misunderstood by the many parochial
parties with atheistic origins. 'Pseud' was mistakenly used by Aramugham of the
Dravida Pride Party (DPP), to refer to a phonetically similar word meaning hot in
Tamil. Since then it has been used to refer to the heated fervour with which
partymen have been practising secularism. According to him, it is better to be a
pseudo-secularist, a hot secularist, than a 'jill'-secularist. 'Jill' is a commonly
used term in Tamil to mean cold or frozen.
Aramugham said his party believed in worshipping actors and actresses equally,
irrespective of their cine-idol's faith, making them pseudo-secular.
The popularity of the 'pseudo' usage was evident with Tamil Nadu's Chief Minister
Jayalalithaa, naming her recently adopted daughter Pseudamani. "After all, what will
I do with all my assets," she said, referring to her vast wealth.
Her earlier adoptee, a son, now disowned had cost her a lot of money in wedding
expenses. "I have something to look forward to in the wedding of Pseudamani,"
Jayalalithaa said at the time of the adoption.
Besides the political and etymological concerns associated with the usage, there
have been lexical concerns too. Due to the frugal use of consonants in the Tamil
language, the "Real Tamil Club", a non-profit organisation in TN that promotes the
use of Tamil in the state has decided that they will drop the letter 'P' in front
of 'pseudo' as they think it is confusing their members and making transliterator's
jobs complicated.
Hindi speaking members were also finding it difficult to use the shortened 'pa'
and 'sa' consonants in the beginning of a word. Pandit Vishwanath of the 'Prakrithik
Bhasha Adyayan Kendra', has recommended the use of the sound 'ae' to precede the
word 'pseudo'. He said 'epsuedo' is easier to use with the local languages.
Meanwhile, the Prime Minister's office when contacted about Vajpayee
attending 'Iftar', gave a curt written response. The PM was hungry, and besides, the
biryani was good, the statement said.