New Delhi: Holding that right to privacy is not an absolute right, the Supreme Court
in a landmark ruling has said a matrimonial court had the power to order medical
examination of one of the spouses in cases where divorce is being sought on health
grounds.
While cautioning the courts not to order a roving inquiry about a person in a
matrimonial dispute, a Bench comprising Chief Justice V N Khare, Justice S B Sinha
and Justice A R Lakshmanan said, "A matrimonial court has the power to order a
person to undergo medical test."
This judgement came on a petition filed by one Sharda challenging a Rajasthan High
Court order upholding a directive of a matrimonial court asking her to undergo
medical test on a petition for divorce filed by her husband alleging her to be
of "unsound mind".
Rejecting the contention that ordering of medical test would be violative of right
to privacy, the court said, "When there is no right to privacy specifically
conferred by Article 21 and with the extensive interpretation of the
phrase 'personal liberty' this right has been read into Article 21, it cannot be
treated as absolute right."
Justice Sinha, writing the judgement for the Bench, said directing a party to the
divorce proceedings to undergo medical test to gather material crucial to the
decision of the case would "not be in violation of the right to personal liberty
under Article 21 of the Indian Constitution".
PTI