JPC may cover all drinks, confused on liquor
Tuesday, September 16 2003 18:21 Hrs (IST)
New Delhi: The Joint Parliamentary Committee (JPC) set up to probe allegations of high levels of
pesticides in soft drinks has expanded ambit of its investigations to cover all packed beverages including
iced tea and juices but appears vague on whether alcoholic beverages should also be covered.
At its first meeting, the 15-member JPC headed by NCP (Nationalist Congress Party) leader Sharad
Pawar deliberated on the scope of its probe and is expected to suggest safety standards for ground
water, one of the principal ingredients in the manufacture of all beverages, sources said in New Delhi.
While one of the members said the probe would cover all beverages including liquor, another said the
scope of the investigation was vague on the subject.
The JPC members witnessed presentations from two laboratories, Central Food Laboratory and Central
Food Technological Research Institute, which had earlier tested the soft drink samples, besides the one
from Centre for Scientific and Industrial Research chief R A Mashelkar on the testing methodology used
for detection of pesticides.
The JPC was set up in August to probe the report of Delhi-based Centre for Science and Environment
(CSE), which had claimed that a high percentage of pesticide residues was present in Coca Cola, Pepsi
and 10 other soft drink brands and it was harmful for health.
"This JPC had been set up to probe allegations of pesticides in soft drinks, but it should cover all
beverages since the basic ingredient - water is common....these include things like iced tea and
juices.....I do not expect the report to be ready before the next session of Parliament," sources said
adding the panel's terms of reference were vague on whether liquor also fell in its ambit.
Sources said what needed to be decided was the method of detection of pesticide contamination and
the permissible quantity and such definitions may be decided by the JPC.
The JPC comprises 10 Lok Sabha members, while the remaining five are from Rajya Sabha.
Sources said some members of JPC wanted liquor also to be covered under the probe since the terms
of reference were vague on the issue. JPC was also not sure on the number of ministries and
government departments concerned in the matter.
"Apart from three separate ministries involved in devising safety standards for beverages - Health and
Family Welfare, Food Processing and Consumer Affairs - the Women and
Child Welfare Department needs to be consulted for beverages meant for children," they said.
The JPC may even recommend setting up of an independent body for devising comprehensive safety
guidelines, they added.
Besides Pawar, Lok Sabha members in the committee include Ananth Kumar and Sudha Yadav (BJP),
Ramesh Chennithala and Avtar Singh Bhadana (Congress), K Yerranaidu (TDP), E Ahmed (ML), Ranjit
Kumar Panja (Trinamool Congress), Akhilesh Yadav (Samajwadi Party) and Anil Basu (CPI-M).
Rajya Sabha members are; S S Ahluwalia (BJP), Prithviraj Chauhan (Congress), Sanjay Nirupam (Shiv
Sena), Prem Chand Gupta (RJD) and Prasanta Chatterjee (CPI-M).
The JPC is scheduled to hold its second meeting in early October.
PTI
What do you think of this article ? Click here to post your views

Related Links
'Pepsi, Coke contain deadly cocktail of pesticides'
Pepsi, Coke dismiss charge of excess pesticides
|