Questions & Answers on Kanchi Mutt and the Seer
by S Karunalingam Tuesday, December 14 2004 18:10 Hrs (IST) - World Time
This is the contribution of a chairman of a private charitable trust in Europe. The full text of the letter is published below:
Leading dailies ran a full-page advertisement recently from Sri Kanchi Kamakoti Peetam in Delhi. This is issued in public interest by the Manager, Sri Kanchi Kamakoti Peetam, Kanchipuram with the support of the devotees from all over the world. The ad was carried in 20 leading dailies in several Indian languages and English, in National and regional newspapers.
This is extremely informative and provides answers and rebuttal to the serious allegations against His Holiness. The page is styled in Question/ Answer format. You can open it from.
Q1: What is the truth about the real wealth of the Kanchi Mutt? Is it 15,000 crores, 10,000 crores or 5,000 crores?
A: Various TV Channels, and Newspapers have reported that Sri Kanchi Kamakoti Peetam is worth Rs. 14,000 crores, Rs. 10,000 crores, Rs. 1000 crores and so on. We too wish they were true, but the reality is different. The Mutt essentially comprises of itself, its branches and a few Trusts, which are directly controlled by it. Most of the other Trusts are independently run and funds, activity and investments are managed by them.
The Mutt has no say in these Trusts and their accounts are not consolidated with the Mutt. The Mutt does not have any access to their funds and cannot draw anything from their resources.
The landed estates of the Mutt have been gifted to it over several generations by Royalty and Devotees and the several endowments created by them for specific purposes continue to remain. If the loan taken by Kanchi Kamakoti Sankara Hospital (Rs. 64.98 crores) is taken into account, the residual cash, bank balances and investments of the Mutt are too meagre even to warrant a mention. The Mutt runs with Kanikkai (contributions) from the devotees and the accounts are professionally audited and the returns filed with Income Tax Department and estate accounts filed regularly with HRCE Department of the Tamil Nadu Government.
Q2: Why are people making allegations about misconduct by His Holiness?
Why are people making allegations about misconduct by His Holiness?
A: A writer, Ms Anuradha Ramanan has claimed that she was victimized by the Seer. Frankly, we are shocked and disgusted by such slander. Why would some one? that too a prolific writer with the power of the pen, who claims to have been victimised in 1992, come out with the allegation now? Why was she silent for 12 long years? Who is behind her disclosure now? Why did she preside over the function at the Kanchi Kamakoti Childs Trust Hospital on 01.08.2003, if she had such ill feeling towards the Acharya and the Mutt? We ourselves would like answers to these questions.
In another instance, the police claimed that a 'deserted woman' Usha staying at Srirangam used to converse with His Holiness regularly and that she was provided with free quarters to stay. Substantial sums of money had been transferred to her through bank. Smt Usha a cancer patient who has undergone 130 chemotherapy sessions, appeared before the police on 30.11.2004 on her own volition and submitted all bank accounts and medical records.
Dinamalar (regional daily) dated 2.12.2004 reports that she was interrogated and after receiving her explanations she was released. Smt. Usha is not the only cancer patient who has received such help. The Sri Matha Trust run under the auspices of the Mutt provides free accommodation, and food not only to the patients seeking admission to Cancer Institute Adyar, but also to their close relatives/attendants.
Q3: Media has been publishing and telecasting news that the Swamiji has confessed. What is the truth?
A: "His Holiness says this is totally untrue". On 29.11.2004 the prosecution claimed that His Holiness has confessed and they have it on video-tape. The claim of confession of His Holiness, as stated in the High Court, is only the statement of the senior counsel, on instruction during the proceedings and is, significantly not found in the counter affidavit filed by the government in the high court. Smt. Sushma Swaraj, MP, the three Supreme Court advocates and the manager of the Mutt, who met the Swamiji in Vellore prison on different dates have confirmed that the Swamiji denied having made any confession.
Remember that two people who were part of the 'clinching evidence' of the prosecution retracted their statements in the open court. They clearly declared that it was under extreme physical torture and abuse that they had implicated His Holiness in the case. The attempt now seems to be, to convict him in the media.
Q4: What is the Mutt's answer regarding the allegation on Cellphones usage?
A: Police claimed that they have a pattern series of telephone calls between the Swamiji and the henchmen and his associates on the day prior to the murder and after the murder. It was later modified and represented by the police in the court that the cell phone did not belong to the Swamiji but it was the manager of the Mutt who owned the cell phone. The Mutt further confirmed that the cell phone referred to did not belong to the manager. The police then claimed that this is not the stage that further details can be disclosed in the matter.
Q5:What about huge cash withdrawals from the bank accounts of the Mutt? Where did the money go?
A: The prosecution charged that huge cash withdrawals were made from the Mutt's bank accounts to pay the ransom to the alleged killers of Sankara Raman. From ICICI Bank to Indian Bank to ICICI Bank Account of an Individual, prosecution has been shifting stance. THE TRUTH IS, THERE WAS NO WITHDRAWAL AS ALLEGED.
Here is the summary of the bank accounts of the Mutt for the period April 2004 to September 2004.
Sr.No.
Date
Cheque No
Amount (Rs.)
Details
1
02-04-2004
852068
30000
Imprest
2
24-05-2004
277873
90000
Jankalyan Trust
3
25-05-2004
277898
31885
Re-deposited
4
30-06-2004
280765
34285
Salary
5
20-07-2004
281500
100000
VidwatSambhavna
6
29-07-2004
278840
500000
Expenses for 70th Jayanthi
7
31-07-2004
278847
32135
Salary
8
03-08-2004
278853
40000
Advaitha Sabha a/c
9
02-09-2004
297237
39185
Salary
Note: Out of total amount of Rs.6,00,000/- withdrawn on 20.7.2004 & 29.7.2004, a sum of Rs.5,99,107/- was paid as Sambhavana to Vedic Pundits godhanam & other expenses on the occasion of Bhimaratha Shanti (70th birthday). The balance of Rs.893/- was re-deposited into the account.
In addition to the above account, five trust accounts are operated by the Srikaryam & the Manager of the Mutt as Authorised Signatories. There are no cash withdrawals from the five trust accounts from 1st April 2004 till 30th September 2004.
Q6:There is a charge that Gold collected for the Kamakshi Amman temple was misappropriated. The entire quantity collected was not used. Where has the balance gold gone?
A: The charge by Sankararaman that 100 kgs of gold were imported to make a gold chariot for Kanchi Kamakshi deity and only 35 kgs were used while the remaining went missing, was re-iterated by the police in the High Court for probe.
Here are the facts.
Sri. Adi Sankarar Swarna Vimana Trust with registered office at VHS Campus, Chennai 600 113 was entrusted with the Gold cladding work of Sri Adi Sankarar Vimanam, Sri Kamakshi Ambal Vimanam and Simha Vahanam.
The board of trustees of this trust comprised of eminent persons. The gold cladding work was done on copper sections by the conventional methods of beating gold strips into foils and pasting the gold foils over mercury base, heating and polishing. The entire gold plating work was completed and handed over to the authorities of Sri Kamakshi Ambal Devasthanam, Kanchipuram as per the details given below.
The trust imported 85.31 kgs of Gold (and not 100 kgs as alleged) comprising of Gold bars 71.31 kgs, biscuits 14.00 kgs.
This was used as follows:
Sri Adi Sankarar Vimanam
21.875 kgs
Sri Kamakshi Ambal Vimanam - upper portion
5.996 kgs
Sri Kamakshi Ambal Vimanam - lower portion
41.411 kgs
Sri Kamakshi Ambal Kavacham
7.495 kgs
Rajagopuram Kalasam
3.932 kgs
Simha Vahanam
4.430 kgs
Total : 85.139 kgs
The balance gold of 171 gms has been duly accounted.
The full description of the various kanikkais together with the receipt numbers are recorded in the register maintained by the temple trust. These accounts have been verified by the HR&CE department of the government from time to time.
Q7: Had the Swamiji planned to escape to Nepal?
A: The police claimed that a helicopter was hired from Pune and was kept ready at the Hyderabad airport and it was intended to go to Mehboobnagar. The helicopter, the police further claimed, was procured by the friend of the millowner at whose premises Chandramouleeswara pooja was performed by the Swamiji.
The prosecution did a somersault and stated that at no point of time it has alleged that the Swamiji would flee along with his commandos and stated that it was for the Swamiji to escape that a helicopter was stationed at Hyderabad with flight schedule for Mehboobnagar.
To quote TVR Shenoy from 'The Indian Express', Mumbai dated December 2, 2004. "HAL's Advanced Light Helicopter, Dhruv has a range of only 660 km. I am told the Pentagon has some choppers in its arsenal which can do about 700 km, and farther still with the addition of a fifth fuel tank."
With this speed it would require about 12 hours to reach Nepal and a minimum of 5 refuelling stops. Would it ever be possible to escape like this? The Swamiji's Travel programmes are always posted in the official website of the Mutt www.kamakoti.org and every one has access to it.
The Swamiji is a 'Z' category security person surrounded all times by commandos/policemen on duty.
Q8: Who is Sankararaman? What is his connection with the Mutt? What was his conflict with the Swamiji? What had he written in his letters? Why was he killed?
A: First. Sankararaman was never an employee of the Mutt as it is made out to be. He was an employee of a temple in Kanchipuram at the time of his death. Sankararaman wrote several letters to His Holiness over the last several years accusing the Swamiji and several others of various acts of omission and commission, to put it mildly.
He marked copies of several of his letters to the CM, the leader of the opposition, HRCE Department and several other prominent citizens and devotees. Every one just ignored the letters as those of a disgruntled black mailer who was threatening to 'expose' the two Swamijis & The Mutt.
These letters were being freely circulated by Sankararaman. In one of his letters he claims that he was a man of average means and that 'some kind hearted man' was paying for the mass copying and postage of the letters.
We cannot speculate as to why he was killed or who was involved. The only thing we believe unequivocally, is that His Holiness is being falsely implicated in this.
Q9: Who is Radhakrishnan? What is his relationship with the Mutt? Why was he attacked? Who attacked him? Why is the Swamiji implicated in this?
A: Radharishnan is a former associate of the Mutt, and has his own business. In 1994, when it was discovered that he was involved in a malicious defamation campaign against the Mutt, he was relieved of his services. He was one of the trustees of the Sri. Adi Sankara trust, for the golden chariot for Kamakshi Amman. The case about an attack on Radhakrishnan is 2 years and 3 months old. In the FIR filed in this case neither the Mutt nor Swamiji were mentioned.
Q10: If the Mutt is not so rich, how can you afford to pay for such a huge advertisement? Who is paying for this advertisement?
A: This advertisement is appearing in media through the kind courtesy of several of our devotees all over the world who are keen to see that a 2500-year-old heritage is not destroyed by scandalous media.
In this hour of all out assault on the Mutt, It requires large infusion of funds to defend itself and provide the truth and right perspective to all concerned. The Mutt has appealed to its devotees and to all Indians to contribute their might to support it to tide over this crisis.
Q11: So much is claimed about the Mutt's various religious, cultural
& social welfare activities? What exactly are they? How are they Managed?
A: A quick glimpse at the activities and achievements of the Mutt in the last 51 years is a testimony to some one who has been called "The 21st Century Jagadguru" Be it in the field of Education, Vedic Research, Healthcare, Social Welfare or Religion, The Acharya has created enduring institutions that will serve people for several generations.
Education
Sri Chandrasekarendra Saraswati Vishwa Maha Vidyalaya at Enathur near Kanchipuram is a Deemed University. This institution seeks to revive Kanchi's reputation as a 'seat of learning'. An Ayurvedic College devoted to Indian medicine forms part of the Vishwa Mahavidyalaya.
Vedic Education and support
Vedal Patashala located on the Bangalore Highway is perhaps the largest patashala in the world and teaches all the four Vedas. Similarly, Agama Patashalas and Silpa Patashalas give a fillip to temple design and architecture.
Healthcare
The Mutt's foray into Healthcare truly reflects the Acharya's Compassion, Care and Commitment to serving the ailing, poor and needy. The Kanchi Kamakoti Sankara Hospital, Kanchi Kamakoti CHILDS Trust Hospital, Sankara Dev Netralaya, Guwahati, Sri Mata Trust are just a few of the shining examples. 1,75,928 patients were treated free of cost at the Kanchi Kamakoti Sankara Hospital, since commissioning in May 2003.
At the instance of the Acharya, the Mutt stepped in at the right time to help the CHILDS Trust hospital to recover from its financial troubles. Because of professional management provided, the CHILDS Trust Hospital has not only turned around but is also one of the finest paediatric hospitals in the country serving young children who need specialist medical help. About one lakh children receive treatment at this hospital every year. Sri Mata Trust is a unique organisation that supports poor cancer patients and their relatives/attendants with shelter and food during the treatment period. Sankara Dev Netralaya started at Guwahati is an exemplary eye care institution and the only one of its kind in the North Eastern part of the Country.
Renovating old temples and consecrating new ones
The Acharya has performed countless number of Kumbabhishekams to revive old temples and consecrate new ones. (The number could be well over 6,000 in the last 50 years)
Social and Humanitarian Services
At His guidance, several homes for the aged, the destitute and the needy are run under the auspices of the Mutt. There are Old Age Homes in Tamil Nadu, Andhra Pradesh, UP & MP. His Holiness is known for His support of the Goshalas and there are many which are run in Tamil Nadu and in the North.
Encouraging culture, arts, science, and public service
The Kanchi Mutt has had a long tradition of supporting the arts and encouraging artists from all the fields. In keeping with this tradition, the Acharya has instituted several awards.
Saint of the masses
The Acharya has travelled more than a million kilometres on foot reaching more than 3000 villages and small towns. He has been one of the first ones to reach areas hit by natural calamities like floods and earthquakes with help for the affected. He has always lead a very simple life with minimal needs. This simple, selfless Saint of the masses is facing an outrageous charge. Such a charge is directed against the very Acharya whose compassion has reached millions with His helping hand. It is indeed the darkest hour for His devotees and those interested in following the tenets of Hindu Dharma.
Disclaimer: The views and opinions expressed in the aforesaid article belong solely to the writer/contributor. We, Indiainfo.com, do not assume any responsibility, whatsoever, to the contents or their implied meanings.